Use Case: Biotic Interactions - Sottunga Island Melitaea cinxia Population Study

This thread can be used to discuss and provide feedback to the use case on Biotic Interactions - Sottunga Island Melitaea cinxia Population Study.

Unfortunately, I’ll be unable to make it to your scheduled webinar today (i.e., GBIF community webinar: Diversifying the GBIF data model ).

I did already spent significant amount of time commenting on the document re: Use Case: Biotic Interactions - Sottunga Island Melitaea cinxia Population Study.

Unfortunately, the comments are not visible publicly. So, this is why I’ll share them separately here:


Jorrit Poelen
7:33 PM Jan 12
Thanks for inviting me to comment. Some highlevel comments :

  1. Real Life examples - many biotic interactions are already described using various dwc-a models. However, no real life example was listed. Suggest to include real life examples to give a idea of the range of methods to describe biotic interactions that exist today.

  2. Consider technical / social adoption risks - I can see how your proposal make sense for you. However, I imagine that the model might be a bit intimidating for others. How are you evaluating the risks like: adoption, easy of implementation, easy of maintenance, ability to map existing data into the proposed model, performance considerations etc.

  3. Prior Art - many project exist today that have implemented a way to model biotic interaction. However, none of them are mentioned as far as I can tell, only DwC resources are mentioned. I’d suggest to include prior art non-DwC project/tools that are currently providing access to biotic interactions data (e.g. Mangal, Web of Life, iNaturalist, EMu, Specify, Symbiota, Species Connect, IWDB, GloBI)

Hope this helps and curious to hear your thoughts.

-jorrit







Curious to hear thoughts of others.

2 Likes
  1. Anyone who has real-world examples, please provide references to them. This would also help with the preparation of a future webinar on this topic.

  2. We have opened a new topic on Socio-technical adoption as a place for this discussion, which transcends use cases.

  3. We created some narratives, such as this one, from our experience (in this case through participation in discussions in the TDWG Biotic Interactions Interest Group) and recommendations for novel cases (thank you @dschigel). The major goal of releasing use cases is to solicit feedback from stakeholders about a proposed solution, not to make a thorough review of what is being done in the community a priori, for which we do not have the resources to do alone. Thus, use cases are designed to capture exemplar narratives as directly as possible as a starting point for collecting feedback. Please see also the topic Socio-technical adoption.